News & Insights

Revisiting Taking Phones to No Kings; Seminar Series

This newsletter is a free publication by the Institute for Secure Activism (ISA), a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization dedicated to promoting personal security for civil rights, human rights, and social justice activists. We believe that technology should work for activists, and that we can actively limit governments from using technology to suppress activism. We focus on individuals who advocate for LGBTQ+, Black, Indigenous, immigrant and other marginalized communities. We provide hands-on training, instructional guides, and direct consultations to help people in civil society organizations protect themselves and their connections. Please consider making a tax-exempt donation to support our mission.

Subscribe to an email version of this newsletter

No Kings III is Coming

The next installment of the nationwide No Kings protest series is coming up on Saturday, March 28. You may have seen the recent news that Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) are buying commercial ad data. They’re explicitly using it to track both non-citizens’ and citizens’ movements. This reporting shows that the risks associated with taking your phone to a protest have become significantly clearer. If you take your phone to a protest, the government WILL know that you attended, full stop. This is an obvious problem for people attending smaller protests with more elements of direct action than No Kings. Many dedicated activists have already been leaving their phones at home for years.

I wrote about whether to take your phone before the second No Kings event in October 2025. My viewpoint has shifted slightly since then. The first event attracted 5 million people nationwide and the second more than 7 million. Consider the number of people involved, the number of locations, the government’s general lack of interaction with No Kings protestors, and the organizers’ commitments to non-violence and minimal disruption or even discomfort. For these reasons I believe that the government almost certainly won’t confiscate your phone simply because you attend a No Kings event. We also now know that widespread, active electronic targeting (cell site simulators aka Stingrays) at No Kings is less likely than I originally predicted. It’s certain, though, that the US government will definitely use advertising data to identify everyone who attends a No Kings protest.

So… Should you take your phone to No Kings III?

My assessment remains the same: This is complicated. It depends on your threat model (that is, your personal risk assessment) AND your intentions. If you (or your contacts) cannot take the small risk that your phone might be electronically attacked or confiscated, you should not bring your phone to No Kings III. If you cannot risk being identified at No Kings at all, remember that it’s not only your phone that’s tracking you. I talk about the five vectors of Ubiquitous Technical Surveillance aka the Surveillance Economy in my new seminar series (see below!). Traveling to and from a protest will leave trails across all five vectors: Online (the data and metadata to and from your phone), Electronic (your phone’s radios), Financial (whatever you buy on your way to and from the protest), Travel (Metro cards, Uber, etc), and Physical/Visual (cameras, cameras everywhere!). Leaving your phone at home will only partially mitigate two of those vectors. Your presence at No Kings is still potentially knowable through the Financial, Travel, and Physical/Visual vectors. So if it’s too risky to be identified at No Kings, don’t just leave your phone at home: don’t go at all!

In terms of your intentions: No Kings is BIG by design. The organizers intend for the sheer number of people to be an explicit message to the government. If you want to be part of that message and you are willing to be being identified at a No Kings protest, you probably SHOULD bring your phone. If the government is going to make an end-run around the 4th Amendment, maybe we should make sure that they ARE counting all the phones that show up! If you are privileged enough that you can “afford” to be on such a list, take your phone to No Kings. If you want to make a statement by INTENTIONALLY being on such a list, then take your phone to No Kings. Public protest is legally protected under the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. Intentionally stating “I am exercising my right to peaceable assembly in our democracy” is an important form of free speech.

New Seminar Series

We’ve launched a new seminar for groups working on social justice issues, “Digital Security Is Solidarity: We Keep Us Safe Online.” In the seminar I talk about how surveillance capitalism actively exploits the normal, everyday behavior of privileged community members and uses this to target our most vulnerable neighbors. I lay out some ways to take advantage of the limitations of this surveillance to keep yourself and your connections safer. I help participants make practical changes right now to their device and app settings on their phones, and start to change their personal habits to frustrate surveillance. Finally we discuss how our communities can be ready for what comes next.

We’ve also successfully run two sessions of our seminar “Activism Under Surveillance Capitalism.” Jessica from NOVA Blue Squad took some excellent notes on one of my presentations; thank you, Jess! This session explores the intersection of surveillance capitalism and rising authoritarianism. We talk about how commercial advertising efforts have created pervasive tracking systems using everyday technologies, enabling government repression, and undermining activists’ ability to organize and act. There’s an interactive portion where we explore some privacy and security settings on your personal phones. We also discuss strategies to resist digital exploitation and keep our movements, organizations, and selves safe.

If you think that your organization might benefit from one of these seminars, please reach out!

So Many Excellent References

ActivistChecklist.org continues to provide solid, well-researched, comprehensive information on topics of interest to a wide variety of activists. Check out their latest guide, Doxxing Defense.

PrivacyGuides.org is another excellent resource. There are so many useful sections of this website. I like to start at their Privacy Activist Toolbox and work from there.

Please Support Our Security Work

We are continuing to provide direct support to activists on the ground here in the DMV (that’s DC, Maryland, Virginia for our less-local subscribers). Your donations continue to make it all happen. Here are just a few of our current projects:

  • We provide custom encrypted voice communications for community patrols, as they protect some of our most vulnerable community members from abduction and forced deportation.
  • We consult with congregations who are working to provide safe haven for their impacted neighbors.
  • We’re sharing technology and data with activists in Louisiana, North Carolina, Minneapolis, and beyond, giving our ICE rapid responders as much of an edge as possible.
  • We are about to launch a new medical education series including First Aid, Stop the Bleed, CPR and AED Certification, all set in the context of social justice activism and faith-based sanctuary efforts. Your donations help us purchase the necessary training aids and medical supplies.

Thank you!

Please share this newsletter far and wide! As always, thanks for subscribing, send me your questions and comments, and please consider donating. We’re all in this together.

We take care of us, we keep our community safe, we look out for each other. Go do good work!

Brian C. Stearns

Executive Director, The Institute for Secure Activism